John Foster Melts Hearts on American Idol with “I Cross My Heart” A Romantic Tribute to Girlfriend Brooklyn During Top 7 Live Show
With every step he takes on the American Idol stage, John Foster proves that authenticity and heart still matter in music. But during the Top 7 live show on May 5, 2025, Foster took things to a whole new level with an unforgettable performance of George Strait’s timeless ballad “I Cross My Heart.”
It wasn’t just the smooth vocals or the pitch-perfect delivery that made the moment magical — it was the intention behind the song. In a bold, emotional gesture, Foster dedicated the heartfelt performance to his girlfriend, Brooklyn, who was watching from the audience. And as he sang each word with sincerity, viewers across the nation felt the depth of that love.
A Love Song with Real Meaning
Foster’s dedication to Brooklyn brought an added layer of emotion to an already moving classic. Known for his country roots and warm, rich tone, Foster used the moment to showcase not just his voice, but his soul.
The judges, fans, and Brooklyn herself were visibly moved. Her face lit up with pride, joy, and tears — a reaction that told the world just how real their connection is.
Carrie Underwood’s Song Choice — and a Perfect Match
As part of the judges’ song choice challenge, contestants were asked to guess which judge selected their song. Foster correctly guessed that Carrie Underwood had picked “I Cross My Heart” for him — a decision that proved to be pitch-perfect in more ways than one.
“I’ve been in your shoes,” Underwood said after the performance. “I wanted to choose songs that would showcase your voice and touch the audience’s hearts — and I knew this one would be perfect for you. And I was right!”
She went on to call the performance “genuine, comfortable, and absolutely stunning,” earning nods of agreement from Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie, who applauded Foster’s emotional control and storytelling depth.
A Defining Moment for John Foster
From the very first note, Foster owned the stage — not with theatrics, but with authenticity. His delivery of “I Cross My Heart” didn’t just entertain; it connected. In a season full of big voices and bold choices, this performance stood out for its quiet strength and emotional honesty.
Whether you’re a fan of country music or simply appreciate a love story told through song, John Foster’s Top 7 performance was a defining moment — not just in his Idol journey, but in the season as a whole.
Why America Is Falling for John Foster
As the competition heats up, Foster continues to win over hearts with his genuine charm, unshakable vocals, and his ability to bring personal stories to life on stage. His tribute to Brooklyn wasn’t just a performance — it was a love letter, delivered through music in front of millions.
And based on the reaction from fans, judges, and Brooklyn herself, it’s safe to say that John Foster just sang his way into the Top 5 — and America’s heart.
